Function Declarations vs. Function Expressions

Lets start with a short quiz. What is alerted in each case?:

Question 1:

function foo(){
    function bar() {
        return 3;
    }
    return bar();
    function bar() {
        return 8;
    }
}
alert(foo());

Question 2:

function foo(){
    var bar = function() {
        return 3;
    };
    return bar();
    var bar = function() {
        return 8;
    };
}
alert(foo());

Question 3:

alert(foo());
function foo(){
    var bar = function() {
        return 3;
    };
    return bar();
    var bar = function() {
        return 8;
    };
}

Question 4:

function foo(){
    return bar();
    var bar = function() {
        return 3;
    };
    var bar = function() {
        return 8;
    };
}
alert(foo());

If you didn’t answer 8, 3, 3 and [Type Error: bar is not a function] respectively, read on… (actually read on anyway )

What is a Function Declaration?

A Function Declaration defines a named function variable without requiring variable assignment. Function Declarations occur as standalone constructs and cannot be nested within non-function blocks. It’s helpful to think of them as siblings of Variable Declarations. Just as Variable Declarations must start with “var”, Function Declarations must begin with “function”.

e.g.

function bar() {
    return 3;
}

ECMA 5 (13.0) defines the syntax as
function Identifier ( FormalParameterList_opt ) { FunctionBody }

The function name is visible within it’s scope and the scope of it’s parent (which is good because otherwise it would be unreachable)

function bar() {
    return 3;
}

bar() //3
bar  //function

What is a Function Expression?

A Function Expression defines a function as a part of a larger expression syntax (typically a variable assignment ). Functions defined via Functions Expressions can be named or anonymous. Function Expressions must not start with “function” (hence the parentheses around the self invoking example below)

e.g.

//anonymous function expression
var a = function() {
    return 3;
}

//named function expression
var a = function bar() {
    return 3;
}

//self invoking function expression
(function sayHello() {
    alert("hello!");
})();

ECMA 5 (13.0) defines the syntax as
function Identifier_opt ( FormalParameterList_opt ) { FunctionBody }

(though this feels incomplete since it omits the requirement that the containing syntax be an expression and not start with “function”)

The function name (if any) is not visible outside of it’s scope (contrast with Function Declarations).

So what’s a Function Statement?

Its sometimes just a pseudonym for a Function Declaration. However as kangax pointed out, in mozilla a Function Statement is an extension of Function Declaration allowing the Function Declaration syntax to be used anywhere a statement is allowed.  It’s as yet non standard so not recommended for production development

About that quiz….care to explain?

OK so Question 1 uses function declarations which means they get hoisted…

Wait, what’s Hoisting?

To quote Ben Cherry’s excellent article: “Function declarations and function variables are always moved (‘hoisted’) to the top of their JavaScript scope by the JavaScript interpreter”.

When a function declaration is hoisted the entire function body is lifted with it, so after the interpreter has finished with the code in Question 1 it runs more like this:

//**Simulated processing sequence for Question 1**
function foo(){
    //define bar once
    function bar() {
        return 3;
    }
    //redefine it
    function bar() {
        return 8;
    }
    //return its invocation
    return bar(); //8
}
alert(foo()); 

But…but…we were always taught that code after the return statement is unreachable

In JavaScript execution there is Context (which ECMA 5 breaks into LexicalEnvironment, VariableEnvironment and ThisBinding) and Process (a set of statements to be invoked in sequence). Declarations contribute to the VariableEnvironment when the execution scope is entered. They are distinct from Statements (such as return) and are not subject to their rules of process.

Do Function Expressions get Hoisted too?

That depends on the expression. Let’s look at the first expression in Question 2:

var bar = function() {
	return 3;
};

The left hand side (var bar) is a Variable Declaration. Variable Declarations get hoisted but their Assignment Expressions don’t. So when bar is hoisted the interpreter initially sets var bar = undefined. The function definition itself is not hoisted.

(ECMA 5 12.2 A variable with an initialzier is assigned the value of its AssignmentExpression when the VariableStatement is executed, not when the variable is created.)

Thus the code in Question 2 runs in a more intuitive sequence:

//**Simulated processing sequence for Question 2**
function foo(){
	//a declaration for each function expression
    var bar = undefined;
    var bar = undefined;
    //first Function Expression is executed
    bar = function() {
        return 3;
    };
    // Function created by first Function Expression is invoked
    return bar();
	// second Function Expression unreachable
}
alert(foo()); //3

Ok I think that makes sense. By the way, you’re wrong about Question 3. I ran it in Firebug and got an error

Try saving it in an HTML file and running it over Firefox. Or run it in IE8, Chrome or Safari consoles. Apparently the Firebug console does not practice function hoisting when it runs in its “global” scope (which is actually not global but a special “Firebug” scope – try running “this == window” in the Firebug console).

Question 3 is based on similar logic to Question 1. This time it is the foo function that gets hoisted.

Now Question 4 seems easy. No function hoisting here…

Almost. If there were no hoisting at all, the TypeError would be “bar not defined” and not “bar not a function”. There’s no function hoisting, however there is variable hoisting. Thus bar gets declared up front but its value is not defined. Everything else runs to order.

//**Simulated processing sequence for Question 4**
function foo(){
	//a declaration for each function expression
	var bar = undefined;
	var bar = undefined;
    return bar(); //TypeError: "bar not defined"
	//neither Function Expression is reached
}
alert(foo());

What else should I watch out for?

Function Declarations are officially prohibited within non-function blocks (such as if) . However all browsers allow them and interpret them in different ways.

For example the following code snippet in Firefox 3.6 throws an error because it interprets the Function Declaration as a Function Statement (see above) so x is not defined. However in IE8, Chrome 5 and Safari 5 the function x is returned (as expected with standard Function Declarations).

function foo() {
	if(false) {
		function x() {};
	}
	return x;
}
alert(foo());

I can see how using Function Declarations can cause confusion but are there any benefits?

Well you could argue that Function Declarations are forgiving – if you try to use a function before it is declared, hoisting fixes the order and the function gets called without mishap. But that kind of forgiveness does not encourage tight coding and in the long run is probably more likely to promote surprises than prevent them. After all, programmers arrange their statements in a particular sequence for a reason.

And there are other reasons to favour Function Expressions?

How did you guess?

a) Function Declarations feel like they were intended to mimic Java style method declarations but Java methods are very different animals. In JavaScript functions are living objects with values. Java methods are just metadata storage. Both the following snippets define functions but only the Function Expression suggests that we are creating an object.

//Function Declaration
function add(a,b) {return a + b};
//Function Expression
var add = function(a,b) {return a + b};

b) Function Expressions are more versatile. A Function Declaration can only exist as a “statement” in isolation. All it can do is create an object variable parented by its current scope. In contrast a Function Expression (by definition) is part of a larger construct. If you want to create an anonymous function or assign a function to a prototype or as a property of some other object you need a Function Expression. Whenever you create a new function using a high order application such as curry or compose you are using a Function Expression. Function Expressions and Functional Programming are inseparable.

//Function Expression
var sayHello = alert.curry("hello!");

Do Function Expressions have any drawbacks?

Typically functions created by Function Expressions are unnamed. For instance the following function is anonymous, today is just a reference to an unnamed function:

var today = function() {return new Date()}

Does this really matter? Mostly it doesn’t, but as Nick Fitzgerald has pointed out debugging with anonymous functions can be frustrating. He suggests using Named Function Expressions (NFEs) as a workaround:

var today = function today() {return new Date()}

However as Asen Bozhilov points out (and Kangax documents) NFEs do not work correctly in IE < 9

Conclusions?

Badly placed Function Declarations are misleading and there are few (if any) situations where you can’t use a Function Expression assigned to a variable instead. However if you must use Function Declarations, it will minimize confusion if you place them at the top of the scope to which they belong. I would never place a Function Declarations in an if statement.

Having said all this you may well find yourself in situations where it makes sense to use a Function Declaration. That’s fine. Slavish adherance to rules is dangerous and often results in tortuous code. Much more important is that you understand the concepts so that you can make your own informed decisions. I hope this article helps in that regard.

Comments are very welcome. Please let me know if you feel anything I’ve said is incorrect or if you have something to add.

See also ECMA-262 5th Edition sections 10.5, 12.2, 13.0, 13.2

Single Post Navigation

← Older Entry

Newer Entry →